LESSFOR MORE : LOW RATES OF COMPLETION AND HIGH COSTS AT CONNECTICUT’S FOUR-YEAR COLLEGES NICKI GOLOS, AMY DOWELL, KATLYN RIGGINS, & MICHAEL DANNENBERG LESS FOR MORE: LOW RATES OF COMPLETION AND HIGH COSTS AT CONNECTICUT’S FOUR-YEAR COLLEGES November 2019 Education Reform Now CT supports elected leaders who are champions of public education, providing policy expertise and advocacy. Together, we advance ideas and practices based on democratic values--with the goals of increasing equity, protecting civil rights and the social safety net, and promoting great educational opportunities for all. Executive Summary When families invest time and resources in pursuing higher education, they deserve to know their investments are likely to result in meaningful credentials and lead to fruitful careers. To make the promise of a quality college education a reality for all, Connecticut’s system of higher education should create wide and equitable opportunities for students while preparing our broad workforce to meet changing business demands. Unfortunately, in comparing six-year graduation rates and net prices among Connecticut bachelor degree granting colleges, between each of those four-year colleges and respective national peers, and looking at them individually across years, we have found a number of troubling trends in the state’s higher education system. This report examines 22 of Connecticut’s 27 four-year bachelor degree granting programs. (Excluded are schools for which we cannot find national comparison institutions or data.1) In particular, this report identifies three key concerns about how well the state’s four-year colleges are serving students and preparing them to succeed in Connecticut’s workforce: • Too many Connecticut four-year colleges have low rates of completion, either for their general populations or for underrepresented minority subgroups. • Of the 22 Connecticut four-year colleges for which we have comparative data, three consistently graduate less than 50 percent of their entire student bodies within six years of initial enrollment. • Seven consistently graduate less than 50% of their underrepresented minority populations in six years. • Almost half of Connecticut’s four-year colleges charge an exceptionally high net price to students from the lowest income families. • In 2016, 12 Connecticut four-year colleges charged more than double the net price that a national peer institution charged to comparable low-income students. • Most concerning is the set of Connecticut colleges that combine low graduation rates and high net prices for low-income students relative to peer institutions nationally. • We call these four schools “double offenders.” As a state, it’s time for Connecticut to dig into trends like these and begin to identify causes and solutions. Good policymaking starts with understanding the problem and keeping in mind the responsibility that our society—taxpayers and schools alike—has to the next generation of young people. The five Connecticut bachelor degree granting programs that we could not include because they lack comparison data to national peers are: Charter Oak College, Goodwin College, Paier College of Art, Post University, and University of Connecticut - Waterbury Campus. 1 Key Findings On Graduation Rates: Connecticut four-year colleges that consistently graduate less than 50% of their firsttime, full-time student populations within six years of initial enrollment: • Mitchell College • University of Bridgeport • Western Connecticut State University Connecticut four-year colleges that consistently graduate less than 50% of their firsttime, full-time underrepresented minority populations within six years of initial enrollment: • Central Connecticut State University* • Eastern Connecticut State University • Mitchell College • Southern Connecticut State University • University of Bridgeport • University of Hartford • Western Connecticut State University * Notably, Central Connecticut State University’s 6-year graduation rate—both generally and for underrepresented minority subgroups—is consistent with (or even high relative to) national peers. This suggests the possibility that its low completion rates may be related to factors other than institution shortcomings. On Net Price for Low-Income Students: Connecticut four-year colleges that have average net prices for low-income students that are significantly higher than most of their peer institutions serving similar students: • Albertus Magnus College • Trinity College • Central Connecticut State • University of Bridgeport University • University of Connecticut • Connecticut College • University of Hartford • Quinnipiac University • Western Connecticut State • Sacred Heart University University • Southern Connecticut State • Yale University University On Double Offenders: Connecticut’s four-year colleges that have low rates of graduation and charge an exceptionally high net price relative to respective national peer institutions: • Southern Connecticut State University • University of Bridgeport • University of Hartford • Western Connecticut State University Introduction This report uses data submitted by colleges to the U.S. Department of Education’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) and College Results Online (CRO), which identifies schools that have similar characteristics and serve similar student bodies. Using CRO allows us to make apples-to-apples comparisons regarding the graduation rates and costs of Connecticut schools relative to respective peer institutions of higher education.2 The data raise three important concerns about how well the state’s four-year colleges are serving their students: • Too many Connecticut four-year colleges have low rates of completion, either for their general populations or for underrepresented minority subgroups. • Too many Connecticut four-year colleges charge an exceptionally high net price to students from families in the lowest income quintile. • Most concerning is the set of Connecticut colleges that combine low graduation rates and high net prices for low-income students relative to peer institutions nationally. The following pages compare six-year graduation rates and out-of-pocket costs to families (i.e. net price after all grant aid is conferred) among Connecticut colleges, across years, and between Connecticut colleges and their respective national peer institutions. Completion Rates in CT’s Four-Year Programs Six-Year Completion 6-Year Graduation Rate Connecticut has three College Name 2015 2016 2017 four-year colleges that regularly graduate less Mitchell College 39.6% 45.1% 40.8% than half of their firstUniversity of Bridgeport 32.9% 28.8% 41.6% time, full-time student Western Connecticut State University 49.3% 45.7% 44.3% populations within six Source: College Results Online (2015, 2016, and 2017). Graduation rates over time for years of initial enrollment. Mitchell College, University of Bridgeport, and Western Connecticut State University. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_group.aspx. These are Mitchell College, University of Bridgeport, and Western Connecticut State University. The low completion rates at these colleges suggests that the majority of students who enter spend time and incur debt without gaining a credential or degree that will have made their investment worthwhile. Debt without degree is one of the worst higher education outcomes a student confronts. Five of Connecticut’s four-year bachelor degree granting programs are excluded because they are so unique that they each lack a cohort. These are: Charter Oak College, Goodwin College, Paier College of Art, Post University, and University of Connecticut - Waterbury Campus. 2 1 How do we explain these lackluster completion rates? Too often, poor outcomes are justified as being wholly a product of student circumstances beyond an institution’s control — be they academic preparation levels, family environment, income, or race. We disagree and believe the data back us up. In the tables below, the colleges in question have been grouped into cohorts of comparable four-year colleges nationally. This allows policymakers and others to see how these particular colleges perform when compared to other colleges with similar admissions standards, serving similar student populations. It also allows them to make an "apples to apples" comparison and see that (as in K-12 education) what colleges do makes a difference. (One might expect that most Yale students graduate within six years; and, indeed, Yale boasts a graduation rate in the 90 plus percent range, even for its underrepresented minority populations. But not every student is a Yale student, and thus comparisons with Yale’s performance are not always meaningful.) 2016 6-Yr Grad Rate University of Bridgeport and Peer Programs 2016 6-Yr Grad Rate Western Connecticut State University and Peer Programs 2016 6-Yr Grad Rate University of Saint Joseph 63.3% Saint Peter's University 53.8% Westfield State University 66.3% Wheelock College 61.3% Concordia CollegeNew York 53.6% Keene State College 62.8% Clarke University 60.8% Southwestern Adventist University 46.8% Converse College 55.4% Greensboro College 44.3% North Park University 53.3% American International College 43.9% San Diego Christian College 52.1% Mount Mary University 43.4% Bluffton University 49.3% Dominican College of Blauvelt 42.5% Tabor College 48.4 % Alverno College 42.0% North Central University 48.1% William Peace University 41.7% Dakota Wesleyan University 47.4% St Thomas University 40.7% Mitchell College 45.1% McMurry University 36.1% Sterling College 45.0% Limestone College 33.5% Davis & Elkins College 44.8 % Faulkner University 32.1% Defiance College 41.8% Union College 41.6% Kansas Wesleyan University 35.0% Mitchell College and Peer Programs University of Bridgeport Adams State University North Carolina Wesleyan College 28.8% 28.8% 20.7% East Stroudsburg University of Pennsylvania University of Nebraska at Kearney Worcester State University Framingham State University Eastern Connecticut State University Fitchburg State University California University of Pennsylvania Salem State University Southern Connecticut State University Frostburg State University Western Connecticut State University Western Oregon University Valley City State University University of Wisconsin-Parkside 57.3% 56.9% 55.8% 54.7% 54.5% 54.0% 53.8% 51.9% 51.4% 47.1% 45.7% 38.9% 35.0% 24.3% Source: College Results Online (2016). “Similar colleges” to Mitchell College, University of Bridgeport, and Western Connecticut State University—respectively. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_basic.aspx. 2 In the table above, six-year graduation rates for Mitchell College, University of Bridgeport, and Western Connecticut State University are listed relative to their respective cohort of peer institutions. Unfortunately, when compared to schools serving similar populations of students, these three Connecticut schools still perform poorly when it comes to student completion. This is a dubious distinction among Connecticut colleges. Students who are admitted to any of these three schools would be wise to consider other options that might serve them better. Six-Year Completion for Underrepresented Minority Populations The story is especially bleak when the data are disaggregated to show how Connecticut’s four-year colleges are serving students of various races. Of the 22 four-year Connecticut colleges for which comparable data is available, seven consistently graduate less than 50% of their underrepresented minority populations over a period of time stretching six years from initial enrollment. These schools are: Central Connecticut State University, Eastern Connecticut State University, Mitchell College, Southern Connecticut State University, University of Bridgeport, University of Hartford, and Western Connecticut State University. Although, to be fair to these seven, they’re not alone in Connecticut. Nearly half of the state’s four-year programs have missed that same 50% graduation rate benchmark at some point over the last three years. (For a list of schools that miss the benchmark for African American or Latinx populations, see Appendices A and B.) Of note with respect to Central Connecticut State University: When compared to its national peer cohort, its completion rates are less objectionable than the other six 6-Year Graduation Rate for Underrepresented Minority Students College Name 2015 2016 2017 Albertus Magnus College Central Connecticut State University 61.5% 40.8% 50.0% 45.0% 47.8% 40.9% Connecticut College Eastern Connecticut State University 78.4% 89.3% 84.2% 39.1% 48.5% 42.2% Fairfield University 84.4% 84.5% 70.5% Mitchell College 29.0% 48.3% 24.5% Quinnipiac University 69.8% 62.8% 72.9% Sacred Heart University Southern Connecticut State University 52.9% 60.4% 71.4% 44.3% 40.1% 43.5% Trinity College United States Coast Guard Academy 84.2% 87.5% 82.9% ds 75.0% 81.4% University of Bridgeport 29.2% 25.5% 34.5% University of Connecticut University of ConnecticutAvery Point University of ConnecticutStamford University of ConnecticutTri-Campus 72.7% 73.1% 74.3% 48.3% 40.6% 58.1% 59.7% 50.0% 63.2% 55.6% 41.5% 41.9% University of Hartford 41.9% 46.1% 43.9% University of New Haven 44.0% 42.6% 52.0% University of Saint Joseph 48.9% 54.1% 55.3% Wesleyan University Western Connecticut State University 88.1% 87.6% 86.6% 45.0% 42.2% 37.1% Yale University 94.4% 98.60% 98.0% Source: College Results Online (2015, 2016, and 2017). Graduation rates over time for Connecticut four-year colleges. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_group.aspx. 3 consistently low-performers.3 Although Central Connecticut State University’s underrepresented minority population graduates within six years at a disappointing rate, Central still performs better than many colleges nationally with similar admissions standards serving similar students. (For the comparison data, see Appendix C.) In contrast, colleges like Southern Connecticut State University, the University of Bridgeport, and the University of Hartford, to name three examples, do a poor job of graduating various underrepresented minority populations, relative to their respective national peer cohorts. (For instance, the tables below show 2016 6-year graduation rates for Latinx students at these three schools, each compared to its respective cohort of national peers.) 6-Yr Latinx Grad Rate Southern Connecticut State University and 2016 Peers East Stroudsburg 52.4% University of Pennsylvania Lock Haven University California State UniversitySan Marcos Western Connecticut State University Western Oregon University California University of Pennsylvania University of West Georgia Salem State University Kutztown University of Pennsylvania Edinboro University of Pennsylvania Stephen F Austin State University Southern Connecticut State University 6-Yr Latinx Grad Rate University of Bridgeport and 2016 Peers 6-Yr Latinx Grad Rate University of Hartford and Peers 2016 Faulkner University ds Monmouth University 62.6% 50.0% Greensboro College ds Gannon University 62.5% 47.7% Limestone College ds Suffolk University 61.5% ds Hood College 59.1% 46.9% 46.4% 44.4% 42.9% 41.8% 41.6% 39.3% 37.9% North Carolina Wesleyan College William Peace University Concordia CollegeNew York Mount Mary University Alverno College Southwestern Adventist University Saint Peter's University Dominican College of Blauvelt ds 53.3% 57.4% 53.3% 50.0% Lewis University 51.6% 44.3% Eastern Connecticut State University 51.5% 43.5% Le Moyne College 51.4% 43.1% 42.9% 35.1% St Thomas University 38.6% Frostburg State University 34.7% American International College 37.5% Clarion University of Pennsylvania 29.4% McMurry University 32.6% Indiana State University 21.7% Indiana UniversityNorthwest 19.0% University of Bridgeport Adams State University Hardin-Simmons University Pace UniversityNew York 26.3% 25.5% Stevenson University University of New Haven University of Hartford Robert Morris University Widener UniversityMain Campus York College Pennsylvania Norwich University 47.5% 43.3% 41.4% 40.0% 39.3% 39.0% 34.8% Source:: College Results Online (2016). “Similar colleges” to Southern Connecticut State University, University of Bridgeport, and University of Hartford—respectively. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_basic.aspx. Of the seven schools that consistently graduate less than 50% of their underrepresented minority populations within 6 years, only Central Connecticut State University compares favorably to its national peer cohort on all four of the following metrics for 2016 comparison data: 6-year graduation rates, 6-year graduation rates for underrepresented minority populations, 6-year graduation rates for African American students, and 6-year graduation rates for Latinx students. 3 4 The Cost of CT’s Four-Year Programs Low completion rates, particularly ones that impact racial minority populations, raise serious questions about: • • • • The quality of relevant four-year colleges; The possibility of racial biases; The continuation of opportunity gaps in Connecticut; and K-12 achievement gaps that leave racial minorities underprepared for creditbearing college coursework. But the out-of-pocket cost of college to families, particularly low-income families, cannot be dismissed as a critical issue. When students undertake debt to enroll in programs of higher education, and then do not complete those programs, they are often left in an even worse economic situation than before they started. Connecticut College and Peer Colleges Average Net Price for LowIncome Students in 2016 ($0-$30K) Lewis & Clark College $18,864 Macalester College $16,848 Connecticut College $15,498 Reed College $11,963 Franklin and Marshall College $11,849 Mount Holyoke College $11,694 Occidental College $11,547 Trinity University $11,378 Hamilton College $8,631 Davidson College $8,163 Swarthmore College $8,038 Bowdoin College $6,822 Colby College $6,481 Bates College $3,497 Washington and Lee University Colorado College $920 ($1,068) Source: College Results Online (2016). “Similar colleges” to Connecticut College. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_basic.aspx. As compared to peer institutions with similar admissions standards, several four-year colleges in Connecticut report average net prices (that is, price after all federal, state, and institution grant aid is conferred) for low-income students that are quite high. Albertus Magnus College, Central Connecticut State University, Connecticut College, Quinnipiac University, Sacred Heart University, Southern Connecticut State University, Trinity College, University of Bridgeport, University of Connecticut, University of Hartford, Western Connecticut State University, and Yale University all have charged at least double a national peer when it comes to net prices for lowincome students — and that’s for just a single year of higher education. Multiply the difference by four or more years to appreciate the true impact on families. (See Appendix D for a list of CT four-year programs that cost significantly more than most of their respective peers, after financial aid.) 5 Less for More Most problematic is the set of Connecticut four-year colleges that generate low levels of student success and charge a higher net price than other comparable colleges serving similar student populations. This list of double offenders includes the Southern Connecticut State University, University of Bridgeport, the University of Hartford, and Western Connecticut State University. Western Connecticut State University, for example, has an average net price (again, that is out-of-pocket cost after all grant aid is conferred) for low-income students north of $14,000 per year. At $2,707 less per year, Westfield State University, located in Massachusetts, has similar admissions standards, serves similar students, and generates a far higher graduation rate. Comparison: 2017 6-Year Grad Rate 70.0% 60.0% Comparison: Average Net Price for Low-Income Students ($0-30K) $20,000 50.0% $15,000 40.0% 30.0% $10,000 20.0% $5,000 10.0% 0.0% $0 Westfield State University (Mass.) Western Connecticut State University Westfield State University (Mass.) Western Connecticut State University Source: College Results Online (2016). “Similar colleges” to Western Connecticut State University. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_basic.aspx. In the short-term, students and parents deserve transparency about schools that are “double offenders” in the categories of both low completion rates and high out-ofpocket net price. In the long-term, however, policymakers and the state should focus on pushing for meaningful improvement. As a starting point to that conversation, we might turn to studying the schools that are serving students well, particularly underrepresented minority populations, by charging reasonable costs for more acceptable rates of completion. 6 4-year programs that compare favorably with peers in completion rates for underrepresented minorities: • Albertus Magnus College • Central Connecticut State University • Connecticut College • Fairfield University • Trinity College • University of Connecticut • University of ConnecticutStamford • University of Saint Joseph • Yale University 4-year programs that graduate over 60% of underrepresented minority populations within six years: • Connecticut College • Fairfield University • Quinnipiac University • Sacred Heart University • Trinity College • United States Coast Guard Academy • University of Connecticut • Wesleyan University • Yale University 4-year programs with costs for low-income families that compare favorably with peers: • • University of ConnecticutTri-Campus Wesleyan University Source: College Results Online (2016). “Similar colleges” for each Connecticut school. Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_basic.aspx. (See Appendix E for a list of schools with favorable comparative completion rates for underrepresented minorities, Appendix F for a list of schools that graduate over 60% of their underrepresented minority populations in six years, and Appendix G for schools with favorable comparative costs to low-income families.) The table above summarizes schools in Connecticut from whom we might learn powerful lessons about how best to serve underrepresented minority populations. As compared to their respective cohorts, Albertus Magnus College, Central Connecticut State University, Connecticut College, Fairfield University, Trinity College, the University of Connecticut (UConn), UConn-Stamford, the University of Saint Joseph, and Yale University all compare to their peers very reasonably in their completion rates for underrepresented minorities. Of this group, Connecticut College, Fairfield University, Trinity College, UConn, and Yale all graduate more than 60% of their underrepresented minority populations within six years of initial enrollment. Looking at net price, the UConn-Tri-Campus and Wesleyan distinguish themselves for what they charge to students from low-income families, relative to their peer schools. Nationally, we see this same completion phenomenon at schools like Florida State and SUNY-Albany that outperform peer institutions when it comes to serving underrepresented minorities.4 A Word on Minority Teacher Recruitment A final note on minority teachers: Connecticut has made clear throughout recent legislative sessions that increasing the recruitment and retention of teachers of color is a priority for the state’s education system. Attention to and improvement of African American and Latinx student postsecondary graduation rates should be part of any minority teacher recruitment effort. Education Trust (2017). A Look at Black Student Success: Identifying Top- and Bottom-Performing Institutions. Retrieved September 2019 at https://edtrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/A-Look-at-BlackStudent-Success.pdf. 4 7 Many of the schools highlighted in this analysis as being low performers in either rates of completion, net price, or both also house teacher preparation programs. The table below displays the enrollment rates and completion rates for underrepresented minority populations in 2016. Of the listed schools, those with educator preparation programs are highlighted in yellow. College Name 2016 Percentage Underrepresented Minority Enrolled 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Albertus Magnus College 49.8% 40.8% Central Connecticut State University 24.6% 47.8% Connecticut College 12.3% 89.3% Eastern Connecticut State University 17.6% 48.5% Fairfield University 9.7% 84.5% Mitchell College 28.3% 48.3% Quinnipiac University 13.5% 62.8% Sacred Heart University 11.6% 60.4% Southern Connecticut State University 28.1% 40.1% Trinity College 13.2% 88.5% United States Coast Guard Academy 14.4% 77.8% University of Bridgeport 55.0% 25.5% University of Connecticut 14.3% 73.1% University of Connecticut-Avery Point 13.7% 40.6% University of Connecticut-Stamford 34.3% 50.0% University of Connecticut-Tri-Campus 26.5% 41.5% University of Hartford 27.3% 46.1% University of New Haven 20.2% 42.6% University of Saint Joseph 31.7% 54.1% Wesleyan University 18.0% 87.6% Western Connecticut State University 30.7% 42.2% Yale University 18.90% 98.60% Source: College Results Online (2016). Retrieved August 2019 at http://www.collegeresults.org/search_group.aspx. If we are serious about increasing home-grown efforts and minority teacher recruitment, we need to devise strategies for improving the enrollment and completion rates of people of color at these colleges. For transparency and improvement purposes, it would also be helpful if the state published the graduation rates, in-state employment rates as teachers, and retention rates in the field for educator preparation programs at these institutions. 8 Methodology The data for this analysis, drawn from the U.S. Department of Education’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS), is based on the performance of firsttime, full-time students. Not included are transfer students and part-time students. Of note, however, nationally, part-time students graduate at substantially lower rates than first-time, full-time students.5 In other words, their inclusion would make most institution graduation rates look worse. Peer institutions are drawn from College Results Online (CRO), which uses an algorithm to identify schools that have similar characteristics and serve similar student bodies. Rather than only comparing Connecticut schools to one another outright — some of which serve widely different student populations and have widely different admissions standards — using CRO peer groups facilitates a more “apples-to-apples” comparison of the data. For every four-year Connecticut college that we analyzed, we compared its 2016 IPEDS data to a cohort of similar national institutions from CRO. We used 2015, 2016, and 2017 data when comparing Connecticut colleges to each other. Because of the nature of these data sources, our analysis looks solely at data from four-year colleges and does not include data on community colleges, which lack a comparable peer group set on CRO. Also excluded are six four-year Connecticut colleges that are so unique that they lack peer groups in the CRO system. Radford, A., et. al. (National Center for Education Statistics, 2010). Persistence and Attainment of 2003-04 Beginning Postsecondary Students: After 6 Years, Table 1. Retrieved October 2019 at https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2011151. 5 9 Appendices Appendix A. 2016 Data: Connecticut Colleges That Graduated Less Than 50% of African American Students Within 6-Years. 2016 African American 6-Year Grad Rate College Name University of Hartford 46.7% Albertus Magnus College 45.9% Eastern Connecticut State University 44.6% Southern Connecticut State University 44.0% University of New Haven 42.9% University of Saint Joseph 42.3% Central Connecticut State University 39.4% Mitchell College 36.4% Western Connecticut State University 36.4% University of Bridgeport 25.5% Appendix B. 2016 Data: Connecticut Colleges That Graduated Less Than 50% of Their Latinx Students Within 6-Years. 2016 Latinx 6-Year Grad Rate College Name Western Connecticut State University 46.9% University of Connecticut-Stamford 46.6% University of New Haven 43.3% University of Connecticut-Avery Point 41.7% University of Hartford 41.4% Albertus Magnus College 36.4% Southern Connecticut State University 35.1% University of Connecticut-Tri-Campus 33.7% University of Bridgeport 26.3% Appendix C. 6-Year Graduation Rate for Central Connecticut State University and Peer Programs in 2016 6-Year Grad Rate Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Bridgewater State University 58.6% 53.2% African American 6-Year Grad Rate 60.7% Farmingdale State College 53.4% 47.5% 52.6% 46.3% University of Northern Colorado 48.4% 43.6% 40.6% 44.6% Central Connecticut State University 53.7% 47.8% 39.4% 54.4% William Paterson University of New Jersey 50.9% 44.0% 38.3% 47.6% Central Connecticut State University and Peer Programs in 2016 Latinx 6-Year Grad Rate 46.8% i Murray State University 48.6% 36.0% 36.8% 32.0% Saint Cloud State University 44.1% 37.1% 35.9% 40.0% Central Washington University 52.5% 50.9% 35.7% 55.5% University of Central Missouri 52.8% 38.6% 34.9% 52.2% Marshall University 44.8% 32.1% 34.4% 25.0% Pittsburg State University 48.0% 42.6% 31.4% 46.8% Northern Michigan University 46.8% 33.7% 30.0% 37.1% Northern Kentucky University 37.6% 23.7% 22.7% 25.0% Saginaw Valley State University 38.0% 20.9% 19.5% 35.7% University of Southern Indiana 37.7% 21.5% 18.1% 36.8% Indiana University-Purdue University-Fort Wayne 23.8% 12.1% 5.2% 23.0% Appendix D. Connecticut Colleges with Net Prices for Low-Income Students That Are At Least Twice That of a National Peer College Albertus Magnus College and Peer Colleges in 2016 Felician College Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) Farmingdale State College $3,064 $13,804 Northern Kentucky University $3,464 Nyack College $13,893 Indiana University-Purdue University-Fort Wayne $5,452 Mary Baldwin College $14,602 Marshall University $6,615 Marygrove College $14,623 University of Southern Indiana $7,310 Dominican College of Blauvelt $14,983 Murray State University $7,421 Ferrum College $15,257 Northern Michigan University $7,737 Concordia College-New York $15,330 Central Washington University $8,693 Lincoln College $15,447 Pittsburg State University $10,132 Alverno College $17,119 University of Central Missouri $10,951 Grace Bible College $12,181 Central Connecticut State University and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) William Peace University $19,000 Saint Cloud State University $11,087 American International College $19,170 Saginaw Valley State University $11,940 Newbury College $21,288 Central Connecticut State University $13,002 Everglades University $24,459 William Paterson University of New Jersey $13,710 Albertus Magnus College $24,902 Bridgewater State University $15,805 Greensboro College $25,378 University of Northern Colorado $16,776 Connecticut College and Peer Colleges in 2016 Colorado College Washington and Lee University Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) Quinnipiac University and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) -$1,068 Salve Regina University $14,034 $920 John Carroll University $16,358 ii Bates College $3,497 Siena College $16,379 Colby College $6,481 Otterbein University $17,238 Bowdoin College $6,822 Saint Anselm College $18,601 Swarthmore College $8,038 Duquesne University $19,546 Davidson College $8,163 Seton Hall University $19,877 Hamilton College $8,631 University of San Francisco $19,955 Trinity University $11,378 University of St Thomas $20,910 Occidental College $11,547 Roanoke College $21,655 Mount Holyoke College $11,694 Xavier University $22,444 Franklin and Marshall College $11,849 University of Scranton $23,219 Reed College $11,963 Biola University $24,595 Connecticut College $15,498 Quinnipiac University $30,412 Macalester College $16,848 High Point University $33,580 Lewis & Clark College $18,864 Pratt Institute-Main $41,227 Sacred Heart University and Peer Colleges in 2016 Harding University Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) Southern Connecticut State University and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) $12,338 Indiana University-Northwest $5,142 York College Pennsylvania $17,238 California State University-San Marcos $5,417 Monmouth University $17,763 Stephen F Austin State University $6,876 Providence College $19,510 Indiana State University $7,840 Xavier University $22,444 Western Oregon University $12,189 Marist College $22,458 Edinboro University of Pennsylvania $12,288 University of Scranton $23,219 University of West Georgia $12,940 Belmont University $23,754 Salem State University $12,951 Loyola University Maryland $24,470 Southern Connecticut State University $13,571 University of New Haven $24,667 Lock Haven University $13,943 Roger Williams University $26,050 East Stroudsburg University of Pennsylvania $14,491 Endicott College $27,007 Frostburg State University $14,924 Saint Joseph's University $27,875 Clarion University of Pennsylvania $15,088 Bryant University $29,966 Kutztown University of Pennsylvania $15,208 Sacred Heart University $32,703 Western Connecticut State University $15,556 High Point University $33,580 California University of Pennsylvania $15,810 University of Bridgeport and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) Trinity College and Peer Colleges in 2016 Colorado College Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) ($1,068) Saint Peter's University $10,472 iii Bates College $3,497 Adams State University $11,446 Gettysburg College $9,956 Mount Mary University $13,430 Skidmore College $11,071 Dominican College of Blauvelt $14,983 Trinity University $11,378 Concordia College-New York $15,330 Franklin and Marshall College $11,849 St Thomas University $15,760 Dickinson College $11,974 North Carolina Wesleyan College $16,208 Denison University $12,098 Southwestern Adventist University $16,921 St Lawrence University $12,384 Alverno College $17,119 Muhlenberg College $12,422 McMurry University $18,888 Trinity College $14,221 William Peace University $19,000 The College of Wooster $14,420 American International College $19,170 Connecticut College $15,498 Faulkner University $19,835 Hobart William Smith Colleges $15,660 Limestone College $22,303 Macalester College $16,848 University of Bridgeport $22,361 Rhodes College $16,979 Greensboro College $25,378 Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) University of Hartford and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill $3,889 Eastern Connecticut State University $12,991 Brigham Young University-Provo $8,939 Hood College $13,918 Stony Brook University $8,954 Hardin-Simmons University $15,349 University of Massachusetts-Amherst $9,639 Lewis University $16,061 SUNY at Binghamton $11,086 Le Moyne College $17,085 University of Connecticut $11,626 York College Pennsylvania $17,238 University at Buffalo $11,637 Gannon University $17,747 University of Delaware $11,750 Monmouth University $17,763 Miami University-Oxford $13,759 Robert Morris University $20,697 George Mason University $15,089 Norwich University $21,708 Syracuse University $17,662 Stevenson University $22,046 University of Pittsburgh-Pittsburgh Campus $21,581 Pace University-New York $24,075 Boston University $21,773 Suffolk University $24,359 Drexel University $25,332 University of New Haven $24,667 DePaul University $25,830 University of Hartford $26,271 Baylor University $27,222 Widener University-Main Campus $26,481 University of Connecticut and Peer Colleges in 2016 Western Connecticut State University and Peer Colleges in 2016 University of Wisconsin-Parkside Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) $7,119 Yale University and Peer Colleges in 2016 University of Chicago Average Net Price for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) $2,551 iv Valley City State University $9,641 Yale University $5,171 Fitchburg State University $11,055 Columbia University in the City of New York $9,481 Westfield State University $12,038 Western Oregon University $12,189 University of Nebraska at Kearney $12,417 Salem State University $12,951 Eastern Connecticut State University $12,991 Southern Connecticut State University $13,571 Framingham State University $13,636 East Stroudsburg University of Pennsylvania $14,491 Keene State College $14,683 Frostburg State University $14,924 Worcester State University $15,298 Western Connecticut State University $15,556 California University of Pennsylvania $15,810 Appendix E. 2016 Data: Connecticut Colleges With 6-Year Graduation Rates for Underrepresented Minority Populations That Fall Within the Top Third of Their Cohorts of National Peers. Albertus Magnus College and Peer Programs in 2016 Grace Bible College Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Central Connecticut State University and Peer Programs in 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate ds Bridgewater State University 53.2% Everglades University 53.0% Concordia College-New York 44.7% William Peace University 43.5% Central Washington University Central Connecticut State University Farmingdale State College William Paterson University of New Jersey University of Northern Colorado 50.9% 47.8% 47.5% Mary Baldwin College 42.4% 44.0% Albertus Magnus College 40.8% Dominican College of Blauvelt 39.7% Pittsburg State University 42.6% Felician College 39.2% University of Central Missouri 38.6% Greensboro College 39.1% Saint Cloud State University 37.1% Newbury College 43.6% 38.8% Murray State University 36.0% American International College 35.6% Northern Michigan University 33.7% Alverno College 33.3% Marshall University 32.1% Nyack College 24.8% Ferrum College 22.1% Marygrove College 20.0% Lincoln College 0.0% Northern Kentucky University University of Southern Indiana Saginaw Valley State University Indiana University-Purdue University-Fort Wayne 23.7% 21.5% 20.9% 12.1% v Connecticut College and Peer Programs in 2016 Washington and Lee University Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Fairfield University and Peer Programs in 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate 100.0% Fairfield University 84.5% 93.5% Bentley University 83.3% Colorado College 91.8% Hobart William Smith Colleges 80.8% Connecticut College 89.3% Marist College 78.6% Swarthmore College 88.9% Loyola University Maryland 77.8% Bowdoin College 87.6% Emerson College 77.4% Franklin and Marshall College 87.0% University of Scranton 72.5% Bates College 86.5% Providence College 68.3% Occidental College 84.8% Roger Williams University 66.7% Colby College 83.9% Drake University 65.9% Hamilton College 83.6% Bryant University 64.1% Macalester College 82.5% Saint Joseph's University 63.0% Mount Holyoke College 80.5% Creighton University 62.1% Trinity University 67.6% Butler University 60.0% Lewis & Clark College 67.5% Xavier University 58.3% Reed College 59.3% Yeshiva University 45.5% Davidson College Trinity College and Peer Programs in 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate University of Connecticut and Peer Programs in 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Colorado College 91.80% University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 85.9% Connecticut College 89.30% Boston University 85.1% Trinity College 88.50% SUNY at Binghamton 82.5% Skidmore College 87.00% Syracuse University 79.8% Franklin and Marshall College 87.00% University of Connecticut 73.1% Bates College 86.50% University of Delaware 71.5% Muhlenberg College 82.90% University at Buffalo 71.1% St Lawrence University 82.60% Miami University-Oxford 71.0% Macalester College 82.50% George Mason University 71.0% Brigham Young UniversityProvo University of PittsburghPittsburgh Campus University of MassachusettsAmherst 69.0% Gettysburg College 81.80% 70.9% Hobart William Smith Colleges 80.80% Dickinson College 80.60% Denison University 78.90% Stony Brook University 67.2% Rhodes College 77.40% Baylor University 66.1% The College of Wooster 73.00% DePaul University 64.0% Trinity University 67.60% Drexel University 55.6% 67.5% vi University of ConnecticutStamford and Peer Programs in 2016 University of ConnecticutStamford University of ConnecticutTri-Campus University of ConnecticutAvery Point Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate University of Saint Joseph and Peer Programs in 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate 50.0% Dakota Wesleyan University 54.5% 41.5% University of Saint Joseph 54.1% 40.6% Regis College 52.9% San Diego Christian College 52.4% Point Park University 48.1% 98.60% Mount Saint Mary College 45.5% Columbia University in the City of New York 90.50% Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Mont Alto 38.4% University of Chicago 88.10% Huntingdon College 34.7% Howard Payne University 34.5% Yale University and Peer Programs in 2016 Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Yale University Bluffton University 31.6% Lake Erie College 28.9% Pfeiffer University 26.5% Grand View University 25.0% Tabor College 24.3% Defiance College 23.9% Davis & Elkins College 23.8% Appendix F. 2016 Data: Connecticut Colleges That Graduated Over 60% of Underrepresented Minority Populations Within 6-Years. College Name Underrepresented Minority 6-Year Grad Rate Yale University 98.6% Connecticut College 89.3% Wesleyan University 87.6% Fairfield University 84.5% United States Coast Guard Academy 77.8% University of Connecticut 73.1% Trinity University 67.6% Quinnipiac University 62.8% Sacred Heart University 60.4% Appendix G. 2016 Data: Connecticut Colleges With Average Net Prices for Low-Income Families That Are in the Lowest Bottom of Their Cohorts of National Peers. University of Connecticut-Tri-Campus and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price Wesleyan University and Peer Colleges in 2016 Average Net Price vii for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) for LowIncome Students ($0-$30K) Husson University $15,129 Connecticut College $15,498 Bethany Global University $11,825 Oberlin College $14,146 University of Connecticut-Avery Point $4,892 Denison University $12,098 University of Connecticut-Stamford $4,831 Franklin and Marshall College $11,849 University of Connecticut-Tri-Campus $3,730 Mount Holyoke College $11,694 Occidental College $11,547 St Olaf College $10,929 College of the Holy Cross $9,169 Smith College $9,038 University of Richmond $8,681 Wellesley College $8,357 Barnard College $7,335 Colgate University $6,892 Middlebury College $5,788 Wesleyan University $5,647 Vassar College $5,585 viii