The Small Business Loan Programs and Re-Opening NFIB Research Center The Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) and the Economic Injury Disaster Loan (EIDL) program are the two primary loan arrangements, and for many, the only loan programs available to small business owners in need of financial assistance. After a brief lapse in funding, the PPP loan program is back online, facilitating loans and accepting new applicants. The EIDL program is also back online and processing loans with new funding, but currently closed to new applicants other than businesses in the agriculture industry. The terms and conditions of a PPP loan are, on its surface, very attractive to most small business owners. If spent correctly, the loan turns into a forgivable grant given certain conditions. Not surprisingly, the loan program is very popular among small business owners with 77% of NFIB members having successfully submitted a PPP loan application. Most of the applications were submitted before the program was suspended for lack of funding on April 16. About 84% of the applications were submitted before April 17 and 16% of applications were submitted after April 17. Half of applicants submitted their application through a small or local, community bank. Another 18% submitted their application through a medium size bank and 14% through a large bank. Approximately 4% submitted their application through a financial technology (FinTech) lender. About 61% of PPP loan applicants have received their loan. This is a significant increase from the last survey conducted on April 16 when 20% of applicants had received their loan. Forty percent of applicants are still waiting, but just under half of those waiting (45%) have received notice that their loan is approved. Once the loan is approved, the bank is required to close the loan within 10 days. Presumably, these applicants will receive their loan within the next week or so. However, just over half (55%) of applicants who have not received a loan are still waiting to hear from their financial institution about their loan status. About 9% of small business owners who have not submitted a PPP loan application were in the process of applying. The remaining small businesses that have not applied, or are in the process of applying, might be on the sideline for a variety of reasons. Such reasons may include lack of interest in a loan, do not or do not believe they qualify, or cannot find a financial institution to submit their application. About 40% of respondents have submitted a loan application for an EIDL and 60% of them applied before April 1. The other 40% applied in April before the program closed to new applicants on April 16. The vast majority (75%) of EIDL applicants also requested the EIDL Emergency Grant. However, 18% of applicants were not sure whether they had or not. Almost half of those who requested the EIDL Emergency Grant have received the funds, many more than the 10% who had received the grant as of April 16. But still, very few EIDL applicants have received the loan itself. Ten percent have received the EIDL and 90% of applicants are still waiting. About three-fourths of respondents are classified as an essential business and 22% classified as nonessential. Five percent of respondents were not sure which category they fell into. However, even though essential businesses are permitted to operate, many are restricted to limited operations, restaurants open only for pick-up and delivery, for instance. Re-opening the economy will involve many challenges including general health risks, supply shortages of personal protective equipment (PPE) products, and regaining consumer confidence. Small business owners have many concerns about re-opening despite half favoring an immediate lifting of non-essential business restrictions and stay-at-home orders. Owners are most concerned with getting customers back to their business with 43% saying they are very concerned, and another 30% moderately concerned. Another significant concern for many small business owners is increased liability. Virtually all small business owners are, to some degree, concerned about increases in liability claims with 38% very concerned about increased liability when re-opening their businesses. Only 6% are not at all concerned. Thirty-eight percent of small business owners are very concerned about their ability to stock up on hand sanitizer and disinfectant supplies, and 31% are very concerned about their ability to adequately supply face coverings. Thirty-one percent are also very concerned about their ability to comply with new federal paid sick leave and emergency family medical leave mandates. The health and safety of employees and customers are also significant concerns with about two-thirds of owners “very” or “moderately” concerned about managing both as the economy re-opens. Fewer small business owners are concerned about finding workers to fill open positions or accessing credit or loan programs as many have likely already applied to either the PPP or EIDL program. While most small business owners want the non-essential and stay-at-home orders lifted immediately or in the next 30 days, most are not expecting the economy to fully rebound until sometime in 2021 or later. The PPP and EIDL Emergency Grants are finally starting to reach the small business sector in large numbers. Small business owners have been eagerly waiting for financial assistance and many are now starting to receive it. However, the EIDL has yet to be widely disbursed in any meaningful way as most applicants are still waiting. These loans will continue to be crucial for small businesses in offering much needed help getting to the other side of the economic disruption. For most small business owners, the move towards re-opening the economy in many states is a welcome development. However, as state governments slowly start re-opening their economies, officials should pay close attention to the concerns of small businesses who are on the front lines of the transition. Methodology This survey was conducted with a random sample of NFIB’s membership database of about 300,000 small business owners. The survey was conducted by email on May 1, 2020. NFIB collected 842 usable responses. Questionnaire 1. Have you submitted an application for a Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loan? 77% 1. Yes 23% 2. No 2. Approximately when did you submit your application? 17% 1. Before April 3rd 54% 2. April 3-10th 13% 3. April 11-17th 9% 4. April 18-24th 7% 5. After April 24th 3. What type of financial institution did you submitted your application? 14% 1. Large size bank (e.g., BoA, Citi, Chase, Wells Fargo) 18% 2. Medium size bank (e.g., Fifth-Third, BB&T, Capital One, SunTrust) 25% 3. Small size bank (e.g., Bank of California, Bank of the Ozarks, etc.) 35% 4. Local, community bank (1 to 5 branches) 4% 5. PayPal, Kabbage, Intuit QuickBooks (or similar) 5% 6. Other 4. Has the loan been deposited to your bank account yet? 61% 1. Yes 40% 2. No 5. If not, have you received confirmation that your loan has been approved? 45% 1. Yes 55% 2. No 6. If you have not submitted an application yet, are you in the process of applying for a PPP loan? 9% 1. Yes 91% 2. No 7. Have you submitted an application for an SBA Economic Injury Disaster Loan (EIDL)? 40% 1. Yes 60% 2. No 8. Approximately when did you submit your application? 2% 1. Before March 16% 2. March 1-15th 42% 3. March 16-31st 32% 4. April 1-10th 8% 5. April 11-16th 9. Did you request the Emergency Grant when you applied for the EIDL loan? 75% 1. Yes 7% 2. No 18% 3. I don’t know. 10. Has the EIDL Emergency Grant been deposited to your bank account yet? 48% 1. Yes 52% 2. No 11. Has the EIDL loan been deposited to your bank account yet? 10% 1. Yes 90% 2. No 12. Is your business considered a non-essential or essential business as it relates to the state’s Covid-19 order? 73% 1. Essential 22% 2. Non-essential 5% 3. I don’t know. 13. How concerned are you about the following when your state re-opens the economy and lifts business restrictions? a. Managing employees’ health and safety concerns 24% 1. Very concerned 40% 2. Moderately concerned 26% 3. Not too concerned 11% 4. Not at all concerned b. Managing customers’ health and safety concerns 27% 1. Very concerned 39% 2. Moderately concerned 25% 3. Not too concerned 10% 4. Not at all concerned c. Getting customers back 43% 1. Very concerned 30% 2. Moderately concerned 19% 3. Not too concerned 8% 4. Not at all concerned d. New workplace safety regulations 29% 1. Very concerned 37% 2. Moderately concerned 27% 3. Not too concerned 8% 4. Not at all concerned e. Increased liability 38% 1. Very concerned 30% 2. Moderately concerned 26% 3. Not too concerned 6% 4. Not at all concerned f. Being able to stock up on hand sanitizer and disinfectant supplies 38% 1. Very concerned 34% 2. Moderately concerned 20% 3. Not too concerned 8% 4. Not at all concerned g. Being able to stock up on face coverings 31% 1. Very concerned 30% 2. Moderately concerned 27% 3. Not too concerned 12% 4. Not at all concerned g. Finding workers to fill open positions 17% 1. Very concerned 20% 2. Moderately concerned 30% 3. Not too concerned 33% 4. Not at all concerned h. Accessing credit or loan programs 24% 1. Very concerned 24% 2. Moderately concerned 32% 3. Not too concerned 20% 4. Not at all concerned i. Complying with the new federal paid sick leave and emergency family medical leave mandates 31% 1. Very concerned 27% 2. Moderately concerned 24% 3. Not too concerned 18% 4. Not at all concerned 14. When do you think is the appropriate time to lift the non-essential business and stay-athome restrictions in your state or city? 46% a. Immediately 31% b. In the next 30 days 7% c. 1-2 months 1% d. 3-4 months 17% e. Whenever health experts believe it’s safe 15. How long do you think it will take before your local economy is back to near pre-crisis levels of economic activity? 1% 1. It is now 13% 2. By July 20% 3. By December 40% 4. Sometime in 2021 19% 6. Between 2022-2024 2% 7. After 2024 5% 8. Other ______________ 16. Please classify your major business activity, using one of the categories of examples below. 12% 1. Construction (general contractor, painting, carpentry, plumbing, electrical, etc.) 9% 2. Manufacturing and mining (dairy processor, printer, publisher, etc.) 5% 3. Transportation, communication, public utilities (truckers, movers, broadcasters, etc.) 5% 4. Wholesale (grain elevator, equipment distributor, manufacturer's rep., etc.) 22% 5. Retail and Restaurants (restaurant, bar, drug store, apparel, etc.) 5% 6. Agriculture (veterinarian, forestry, landscaping, fisheries, etc.) 5% 7. Financial, insurance, real estate 23% 8. Services (auto repair, house cleaning, salon, etc.) 12% 9. Professional services (attorney, physician, skilled nursing, etc.) 2% 10. Other (please describe) ______________________ 17. Number of Employees 7% 1. No employees 14% 2. 1-2 employees 25% 3. 3-5 employees 20% 4. 6-9 employees 17% 5. 10-19 employees 12% 6. 20-49 employees 5% 7. 50-199 employees 1% 8. 200-499 employees