oFy

12/?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Supervisor's Report of Response to Resistance 6
To: Allredo Ramirez Iii, Director. Miami-Dada Police Departmeur Page 1 0/ 3
Miami-Dade County Florida MDPD Care Numlm PD200531178601
093112020 m, SUN rm, 1540
From: Theodore Tate, Sergeant mm Miami Wm NOD Gm GBP259
Special Patml Bureau may" Moan/Ilene: . Biscayne Boulevard/NE Esme:
0W mm 39
Subjecl Nam: MEL hill) Rice/Sex 617m Age
Alfaro-Funsena, Ariel WIM 23
mmse Wary (cw mam-um Huspiizsigma 3591-17 (mm 41
mar "mum, Warm um um um mum in Sumsm we um
52/53 70 112 Sgt. Theodore Tate Dn scene 1900
mm 1. 7. 2 
Re/usal to Obey Dlsperszl Order
INVOLVED Check if four or more officers/witnesses (use addifional iorrns)
Fm!) Rank Elfin: mm Em Age DMeSwum in:
De la Nuex, Roberto Officer 5470 WIM 43 1fll31I2fl02 125
mm mm mm LevainiFme >10wa
10 MIA 23 64/65 91/93 111/119
"mm m; Badge mm an Age hm
Encinosa. Jorge Officer 7325 WIM 39 D1I28IZD16 126
Ecw rum-m Nosvili u/Fm- n! Farce New Used
10 23 MIA 64 91 111/120
Nam: (Lid. Firs/i Rank 5341>> RemLem alFme m: 6 Fame 
WITNESSES (Badge if sworn officers)
m. (mi, mu m: it mm 
RobertoGiil Z465 -- 
Name [ml Firs>> 11 Wins; Plan
Nmndakecio 3532 -- 
Nam: (mt rm Hang! Adams mm
om ram 5

mumPthgiimx suMaci/s) W, 
Wee/(5) 8169: FM Ya Wile
Lopez, E. 3140 Eisciyne Homeward/ME 5 Sheet !H35.Amznu w" "mini 1930
am: rm to m.
aaiis, v. I mac, 4661/6893 5. America ijJerminal TGK 2355
m: muss mum mama" mm or wave>>: usEn m: or Now User)
Dinette/11mm MW mi mam mm mm. imam "Mm-um
am one unmask) in Die mm. nee/men 5147mm mm. mm simm- mean/HM:
um amus mun my 257mm summed it new>>: svHindi/Amil "2.6mm
non/mm." aLskm msneu 2w. Rami- am ussmwii
mum m) 1275mm 27mm sum>>, lunlzd anul 5, 9mm mm
'ussmuy imam 26mm .m mm mm." Mum mm "5wa
Emilio mun-m inseam "an. 55mm 0mm 75Eiumimi mm" new
AW mm, mm 15mm: suercrEI) murmur mm mm. mm
mm m" rimming mam Emu 3mm ma ar some nmm; 9 "Emu/mm:
0mm mum 314mm mm :m warm mam
new". azoman- We mm. 935mm>> 121mm"
um. mama "Unknown used sum "snow 1mm AM
mm cam-n swim mum: mus." Wnpan
Wm. :cw WM wniacl mm mom
a Heinz: 2mm: nasmven aENAviux mm mm cam:
Menuhin mm mm mum in. umhguidl/ mm mm
KrMexican mm "mm, um mm mm mmdahil m.
teem wuhiniiamsi-aanemm mecw
Awake! was MM mm
IM 0mm uaam (hands but!)


[11.2.9qu

555mm mm mul 
rm mm: mm mm 
useummuemmw

 REPORT OF RESPONSE TO RESISTANCE -- NARRATIVE
Case Number: PD200531-178601

May 31, 2020

Page 3

During the George Floyd protest occurring in the City of Miami, a large crowd assembled
at the entrance to PortMiami, located at the intersection of Biscayne Boulevard, between
NE 5 Street and NE 6 Street. Mr. Ariel Alfaro?Fonseca arrived with a large crowd of
protesters that gathered and assembled, blocking the exit of PortMiami. Mr. Alfaro-
Fonseca was identified as being part of a smaller group of protestors that were throwing
water bottles and rocks at the Miami?Dade Police Department, Rapid Deployment Force.
At this time, a sequence of dispersal orders were read aloud by the Miami-Dede Police
Department, Rapid Deployment Force, Platoon 2 Commander, Lieutenant Vernon
Williams, Badge 5500, Unit RDF2, at?l745, at 1755, and at 1800 hours, respectively.

After the majority of the crowd dissipated, Mr. Ariel Alfaro~Fonseca, who was
accompanied by several other males, remained on the scene, standing in the middle of
the roadway, in contravention of the dispersal order. Officer Roberto De la Nuez, Badge
5470, SRT33, who was assigned to a mobile intervention team, was directed by the
Special Response Team Commander, Lieutenant Luis J. Sierra, Badge 4378, Unit SRT2,
to the area where Mr. Alfaro?Fonseca and the others in his group were loitering. Officer
De la Nuez approached Mr. Alfaro~Fonseca, and advised him that he was under arrest.
At this time, Officer Dela Nuez grabbed Mr. Alfaro-Fonseca with both hands in an attempt
to take him into custody; however, Mr. AlfarouFonseca extended his arms and began
pushing himself away from Officer De la Nuez. Officer De la Nuez then attempted to leg
sweep Mr. Alfaro?Fonseca, who continued to resist his arrest. At the same time, Officer
Jorge Encinosa, Badge 7325, using his right arm, encircled Mr. Alfaro-
Fonseca?s upper torso and head, subsequently redirecting him to the ground. Officer 
Encinosa then placed Mr. Alfaro-Fonseca in flex cuffs without further incident.

Mr. Alfaro-Fonseca had no visible injuries, nor complained of injury. None of the involved
officers sustained any injuries as a result of the incident. Sergeant Theodore Tate, Badge
5749, Unit K9-20, was on scene and conducted the supervisory investigation. Sergeant
Tate interviewed Mr. Alfaro?Fonseca, who did not provide any additional information
pertaining to the incident. Sergeant Tate also interviewed Officers Dela Nuez, Encinosa,
and Officer Armando Recio, Badge 3532, Unit Z1205, and Sergeant Roberto Gill, Badge
2465, Unit SRT60, and their statements were consistent with the aforementioned details
of the incident.

Mr. Alfaro-Fonseca was transported to PortMiami Terminal F, by Officer Eugenio Lopez,
Badge 3140, Unit SEA43, in order to be processed and interviewed by Homeland
Security, Detective Orlando Lopez, Badge 3206, Unit HL54. Mr. Alfaro?Fonseca was
subsequently transported to the Turner Guilford Knight Correctional Center by Miami?
Dade Corrections and Rehabilitations Department Officers Charles Fritz, Badge 6893,
and Valerie Batz, Badge 4661, without further incident.

 

 

"my 01 mm".

POLICE DEPARTMENT PD200531173601

001 06/03/2020
Emu/mum" [jszs Law 

WW I OFFENSEINCIDENTREPORT 

 

 

gRelaled Ew 

Offenders. 1 5mm. mums, a Oflenszs. 1
INCIDENT (NE 6TH ST 8- BISCAVNE BLVD)

m. mcmmum A um 
SPECIAL 05131/2uzn1912 05131120201 12 05/31lznzo1szm
mm

mm",

     

a sARs. NO ay, N0

    

   

 
 
 

  
 
  
 

mm am


Imam 7mm

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

    
  
  

 

  
 

 

05/31/20201745 
Guy 11, Ana
NE 6TH ST 5. EHSCAYNE BLVD M1AMI 33132 1.253
Bum"; mum". Wham>>. rum Envy O'cllpinny
NIA 
OFFENSES
. u. - -
mm". MW.
EMERGENCY MEASURES 87D DAB
mum Wlivum av
M1SDEMEANOR COMMITTED 0075 

vm can: Mani" 
(EXEMPT) 8701048
szu [mm m. mm: Buw'ux] syn-aw: mm mm
SERRA, LUIS AT WORK LAW ENFORCEMENT OFHCER
away
-- DORAL FLOR1DA 3312s US
he. SH nu. =1 am my." m: Elnmuly
WHITE MALE 50 OTHER HISPAMC
mm mm mm ahnrgu'r

 

 

 
      
 
 

humann'w- En-Mmlwun

COUNTY

 
     
 

EMIH mm;

 

mam. sum
FULL VEAR
Phone Numbers
mm" m. 1., 


 

 

 

Relatinnshims)
mun! Iypa swam". mam, 
ARRESTEE ALFARO FONSECA ARIEL STRANGER

 

Page 1 0M

   

3 7:25 ENCINDSAJR

ozuu "11mm:

 

 MM OFFENSEJNCIDENT REPORT WM.
001 06/03/2020 POLICE DEPARTMENT PD200531178601

 

 

 

 

 

Ess

 

 

  

mm, mm.

570 048

  
   
 
 

ww cm

(EXEMPT)
"mm 5mm, vmm:

VERNON AT WORK LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
mm." mm
3317a us

mx-avamn Am mm mm
BLACK OR AFRTCAN A MALE A92 Range 40 TO 50 YR NO AFRICAN AMERKDAN

am hi my pv-Y-uhavyu'!

       
   

      

      

     
 

    

mam. sulus

FULL VEAR

mm. m.

COUNTY

  
  

Em." "mm

 
 

 

Phone Numbers

 

 

 

m: mm." 
BUST NESS
Rel ns

     

5.5>>an mm uVSuhlull-lnavmum 


ARRESTEE ALFARO FONSECA ARTEL STRANGER

THER OR TATE OF FLORIDA
OTHER ORG

 

     

mum mam.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

370.043
mm TM, mm. nr 3mm>> Imu'vemwllAdMly vumm m2
STATE OF FLORIDA GOVERNMENT
mm mm: m. mm
Ru: anagram Au- "va. WWI Emmy
mumsum. Enrnlunmuw mum
mm Emi'lAndlu:

 

 

  
  

Page 2 914

n, mm 1 mm

     

 

mm

06/03/2020

Agm'y Uncumnat

001

 

OFFENSE-INCIDENT REPORT
MIAMI-DADE POLICE DEPARTMENT

"my mm mm

PD200531178601

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SUSPECTS 0R MISSING PERSONS

 

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

pm." Mum
ARRESTEE 370.045
IL. mm" mm." mama
ALFARO EONSECA, ARIEL CUBA, REPUBLIC
sax An- luumIe leplml (mum-y
WHITE MALE 23 YES CUBAN
mm m. aw". Wu,
COUNTY FLORIDA same US
Mummy". 2, Emwmm
my Um, m. m. mm mm cum.>> mm
FLORIDA us
mm mm. mm!
71" or 170035 GREEN SHIRT, BLACK PANTS, RED BANDADA, KHAKI BOOTS
WALKED
mm. mm, mm. 
BROWN BROWN MEDIUM LIGHT
mum. T:th 5pm..
THIN FULL BEARD NORMAL NORMAL
Phone Numbers
"mummy mm "mum"
CELL
OFFICERS
"mm Mg. m. m. m, war-
II 030 5470 POLICE OFFICER DE LA 22043 OFFICER
"mm. m: m: mm cm W:
030 7325 ROLICE OFFICER ENCINDSA JR, I 22042 REPORTING OFFICER
. . . . .
m- um mm Me
030 3272 POLICE LIEUTENA BERMUOEZ, E, 22042 REVIEWING SUPERVISOR
- . - . .
Wm. M: mm. Emu." M, 
CLEAR 5v ARREST 05/31/2020 00 00 NOT APPLICABLE ADULT
sum mama". By "mm mew

 

   

mm." mm
IAMI-DADE

mm mm.

w. "my

 

Vamm nuns: m" mums

       

      
  
   
   

mm ADA Ag. mm. cu.

 

 

 
 

Officer 03 7325 ENCINDSA JR

 

Page a 014

 

 

Agenc'nyOccurence DateWrirten OFFENSEJNCIDENT REPORT AgencyRepanNumber
001 06/03/2020 MIAMI-BABE POLICE DEPARTMENT PD200531173601

I NARRATIVES I

Written By: mdpd\U307325 NARRATIVE Date and Time:?6l3l2020 6:32:32 PM

DURING THE GEORGE FLOYD PROTEST OCCURRING IN THE CITY OF MIAMI, A LARGE CROWD ASSEMBLED AT THE ENTRANCE
TO THE PORT OF MIAMI, LOCATED AT THE INTERSECTION OF BISCAYNE BOULEVARD, BETWEEN NORTHEAST 5TH STREET
AND 6TH STREET. A DISPERSAL ORDER WAS READ ALOUD BY THE MIAMI-DADE POLICE DEPARTMENT, RAPID DEPLOYMENT
FORCE, PLATOON 2 COMMANDER, LIEUTENANT VERNON WILLIAMS, BADGE 5500, UNIT RDFZ, AT 1745 HOURS, 1755 HOURS,
TAKING EFFECT AT 1800 HOURS.

 

 

         

MR. ARIEL ALFARO FONSECA ARRIVED WITH A LARGE CROWD OF PROTESTERS THAT GATHERED AND ASSEMBLED,
BLOCKING THE EXIT OF PORTMIAMI. MR. ALFARO FONSECA WAS IDENTIFIED AS BEING PART OF A SMALLER GROUP OF
PROTESTERS THAT WERE THROWING WATER BOTTLES AND ROCKS AT THE POLICE, RAPID DEPLOYMENT
FORCE.

AFTER THE MAJORITY OF THE CROWD DISSIPATED, MR. ARIEL ALFARO FONSECA, WHO WAS ACCOMPANIED BY SEVERAL
OTHER MALES WEARING BACKPACKS AND CARRYING MULTIPLE WATER BOTTLES, REMAINED AT 6TH STREET AND BISCAYNE
BOULEVARD, STANDING IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ROADWAY, IN CONTRAVENTION OF THE DISPERSAL ORDER. IN
COORDINATION WITH THE SPECIAL RESPONSE TEAM COMMANDER, LIEUTENANT LUIS J. SIERRA, BADGE 4378, UNIT SRTZ,
LIEUTENANT WILLIAMS ASSEMBLED MULTIPLE TEAMS IN ORDER TO APPREHEND THE LISTED SUBJECTS.

OFFICER ROBERTO DELANUEZ, BADGE S470, SRT33, WHO WAS ASSIGNED TO A MOBILE INTERVENTION TEAM, WAS
DIRECTED TO THE AREA WHERE MR. ALFARO FONSECA, AND THE OTHERS IN HIS GROUP WERE UNLAWFULLY ASSEMBLED.
OFFICER DELANUEZ WAS DIRECTED TO APPREHEND MR. ALFARO FONSECA SPECIFICALLY. OFFICER DELANUEZ GRABBED
MR. ALFARO FONSECA WITH BOTH HANDS IN AN ATTEMPT TO TAKE HIM INTO CUSTODY, HOWEVER MR. ALFARO FONSECA
EXTENDED HIS ARMS AND BEGAN PUSHING HIMSELF AWAY FROM OFFICER DELANUEZ. AT THE SAME TIME, I, WHO WAS
PART OF AN ARREST TEAM AND TASKED TO APPREHEND MR. ALFARO FONSECA, WAS ABLE TO GRAB HIM FROM BEHIND,
AND WHILE CONTROLLING MR. ALFARO UPPER TORSO AND HEAD, EFFECTIVELY DIRECTED HIM TO THE
GROUND. I INSTRUCT ED MR. ALFARO FONSECA TO STOP RESISTING AND PLACE HIS HANDS BEHIND HIS BACK. MR.
ALFARO FONSECA ULTIMATELY COMPLIED, AND I PLACED HIM IN FLEX CUFFS WITHOUT FURTHER INCIDENT.

MR. ALFARO FONSECA HAD NO VISIBLE INJURIES, NOR COMPLAINT OF INJURY.

MR. ALFARO FONSECA WAS TRANSPORTED TO PORTMIAMI TERMINAL F, BY OFFICER EUGENIO LOPEZ, BADGE 3140, UNIT
SEA43, TO BE PROCESSED AND INTERVIEWED BY HOMELAND SECURITY DETECTIVE ORLANDO LOPEZ, BADGE 3206, UNIT
HL54. MR. ALFARO FONSECA WAS SUBSEQUENTLY TRANSPORTED TO THE TURNER GUILFORD KNIGHT CORRECTIONAL
CENTER BY MIAMIHDADE CORRECTIONS AND REHABILITATIONS DEPARTMENT PERSONNEL (FRITZ CHARLES, BADGE 6893
AND VALARIE BATTS, BADGE 4661) WITHOUT FURTHER INCIDENT.

Revised7129I2015 Officer: 030.7325 ENCINOSA JR, J. Page4of4

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case Number P13200531 178601
.Photo Taken By Sergeant Theodore Tate, Bagde 5749, Unit 
Date Photos Taken 05/31/2020
Location of Photos 1567 NW 79 Avenue, Doral, FL 33126 .
Name, Badge and Officer Roberto De la Nuez, Badge 5470, Unit
Rank SRT33

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case Number

PD200531178601

 

Photo Taken By

Sergeant Theodore Tate, Bagde 5749, Unit K9-20

 

Date Photos Taken

05/31/2020

 

Location of Photos

1567 NW 79 Avenue, Dorai, FL 33126

 

 

 

Name, Badge and
Rank

 

Officer Jorge Encinosa, Badge 7325, Unit IMT32

 

 

 

 

-.-A

. paucz. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case Number

PD200531178601.

 

Photo Taken By

Sergeant Theodore Tate, Bagde 5749, Unit K9-20

 

Date Photos Taken

05/31/2020

 

Location of Photos

903 S. America Way, Terminal 

 

 

Subjects Name and
Date of Birth

 

Ariel Alfaro~Fonseca, DOB: 04/11/1997